Newborn Eye Ointment (Erythromycin): Required or Optional?
Understanding antibiotic eye prophylaxis for newborns - when it's necessary, state laws, and your rights to decline.
What Is Newborn Eye Ointment?
Shortly after birth, hospitals apply erythromycin antibiotic ointment to newborns' eyes. This practice, called "eye prophylaxis," is intended to prevent serious eye infections that can be transmitted during vaginal birth.
The ointment is applied as a small ribbon along the lower eyelid of each eye, typically within the first hour after birth (though many parents request delaying it to allow for better eye contact during initial bonding).
What Hospitals Typically Do
Eye prophylaxis is mandated by law in most U.S. states, though the specifics vary. Some states require it unless parents formally decline, while others have stricter requirements.
Erythromycin replaced silver nitrate (which was more irritating) in the 1980s. It's applied routinely to all newborns, regardless of the mother's STI status or mode of delivery, as a preventive measure.
Many hospitals will allow you to delay the application for 1-2 hours after birth to allow for bonding and breastfeeding, but will still require it eventually unless you formally decline.
Why Eye Ointment Is Given
Protection Against Gonorrhea and Chlamydia
The primary purpose of eye prophylaxis is to prevent ophthalmia neonatorum - serious eye infections caused by gonorrhea or chlamydia bacteria that can be transmitted during vaginal birth.
- Gonorrhea: Without treatment, can cause severe eye infection leading to blindness. Now rare in developed countries due to routine screening and treatment during pregnancy.
- Chlamydia: Can cause conjunctivitis and pneumonia in newborns. However, erythromycin ointment is not fully effective against chlamydia (oral antibiotics are more effective if baby is infected).
Historical Context
Eye prophylaxis became universal in the late 1800s when gonorrhea was common and untreatable. It dramatically reduced blindness from neonatal gonorrhea. Today, prenatal screening and treatment have made these infections rare in pregnant women in developed countries, leading many parents to question whether the intervention is still necessary.
Benefits & Concerns
Benefits
- Prevents blindness from gonococcal eye infection (rare but serious)
- Provides protection even if prenatal testing was false negative or if mother was exposed after testing
- Low-risk intervention with minimal side effects
- Provides peace of mind for parents
Common Concerns
- Can cause temporary blurred vision and eye irritation for 24-48 hours
- May interfere with early eye contact and bonding if applied immediately after birth
- Not fully effective against chlamydia (the more common infection)
- May be unnecessary if mother tested negative for STIs and is in a monogamous relationship
- Rare allergic reactions (redness, swelling)
Can You Decline Eye Ointment?
State Laws Vary
Parents' ability to decline eye prophylaxis depends on state law:
- Parental choice:Some states allow parents to decline with written refusal
- Required by law:Other states mandate it for all newborns
- Religious exemption:Some states allow exemptions for religious reasons
Check your state's laws: Contact your hospital or birth provider to understand your state's specific requirements and whether you can legally decline.
Risk Assessment
Parents may feel comfortable declining if:
- Mother tested negative for gonorrhea and chlamydia during pregnancy
- Mother and partner are in a mutually monogamous relationship
- Cesarean birth (no exposure to vaginal bacteria)
- State law permits parental refusal
Important: Even with low risk, there is still a small possibility of undetected infection. Discuss your specific situation with your healthcare provider.
Middle Ground: Delayed Application
If you're unsure about declining entirely, many hospitals will accommodate a request to delay the eye ointment for 1-2 hours after birth. This allows for uninterrupted skin-to-skin contact and eye contact during the critical first hour, while still providing the preventive treatment.
Are There Alternatives?
Short answer: Not really.
Erythromycin is the standard antibiotic ointment used in the U.S. Some countries use other antibiotics (like tetracycline), but these are not available in American hospitals.
Povidone-iodine (Betadine) solution has been studied as an alternative and shows effectiveness, but it's not currently approved or used for this purpose in the U.S.
Your main options are: receive the erythromycin ointment (immediate or delayed), or decline treatment entirely (where legally permitted).
Questions to Ask Your Provider
- What is our state's law regarding newborn eye prophylaxis? Can we legally decline?
- Can we delay the eye ointment for 1-2 hours after birth to allow for bonding?
- What are the actual risks of declining in our specific situation (given my test results)?
- Will my baby still receive the ointment if we have a cesarean birth?
- What brand/type of eye ointment does your hospital use?
- What signs should we watch for if we decline and need to monitor for infection?
- How long does the ointment typically affect the baby's vision?
- If we decline, will we need to sign a waiver?
Want Deeper Research on Birth Decisions?
Our comprehensive Birth Decision Research Guide includes peer-reviewed studies, state-by-state laws, and evidence-based information on eye ointment and 15+ other birth decisions.
Includes lifetime updates and citations from medical journals
Ready to Create Your Birth Plan?
Document your eye ointment preferences and 20+ other birth decisions in a beautiful, professional PDF to share with your care team.
Start My Free Birth PlanMedical Disclaimer: This information is for educational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. Eye prophylaxis laws and recommendations vary by state. Always discuss your specific situation, test results, and state laws with your healthcare provider before making decisions.